Have a tendency to whenever schedules are given, he’s given which have a day of your month one to really does maybe not meets with this date whilst inside the actual records. One particular analogy occurs in Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner regarding Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to 16 October as Saturday, no matter if 16 October 1993 is actually a friday.

You are able, but not unlikely, one to Fudge was speaing frankly about a far more distant ancestor, as Thatcher grabbed workplace before Fudge supposedly turned Minister for Wonders

There are even contradictions during the guides in this field. Such, into the Harry Potter together with Goblet from Fire, one another step 1 Sep and you can 2 Sep are given since the Mondays and, inside Harry Potter and also the Prisoner of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is determined for the 20 April, however, careful parsing of the text indicates that it may provides happened no later on than simply February.

Plus, in Harry Potter plus the Cup from Fire they do say your Champions was basically chosen for the Saturday 31 Oct, but 31 Oct try a monday in the 1994. Yet not, it absolutely was afterwards reported that twenty-two November try a monday, which it was at 1994.

During the chapter 7 out of Quidditch Through the Age, they state that very first Quidditch Business Cup happened during the 1473. If the tournament try stored all of the four years, so it disputes on the declaration from inside the Cup out of Fire your 1994 Industry Mug was new 422nd. If the Quidditch Through the Age is great, brand new 422nd Quidditch World Cup would in fact fall in the entire year 3161, however, if Goblet out of Flame is great, the first Globe Cup was stored inside 306.

Historic trouble

While the show, with respect to the timeline produced by new Chamber out-of Treasures resource, is decided regarding 1990s, the brand new collection usually appears as though it’s devote the fresh new later 1990s to help you middle-2000s, around concurrent on book of the books. In Harry Potter plus the 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to refer into “predecessor” of your own Prime Minister of one’s Uk. With respect to the above schedule, this will take place in the summer away from 1996, if Best Minister was John Big, whose instantaneous predecessor try a woman (‘s basic interviewing Fudge, the publication says this new election, however, Major was not first elected and just took more once Thatcher retired.

(No matter if you can imagine a situation in which Fudge is delegated of the Minister having Secret meet up with toward Finest Minister as he, Fudge, was at an inferior office.) On top of that, the identity and history of the top Minister represented generally seems to more directly meets that Tony Blair than just out-of John Big. A blog post from the Daily Mail notes one to Rowling try personal with the next-Chancellor of one’s Exchequer Gordon Brown (commonly regarded as a competition so you can Blair’s frontrunners of your own Labor Class, just who been successful your and became Best Minister), and therefore she has been trying to tell you Blair’s bad top. In case the books was indeed invest connect having publication time from Philosopher’s Brick, then this event carry out take place in 2002 emo dating advice (immediately following Blair turned into Primary Minister).

A similar disease relates to Nicolas Flamel, who was mentioned as being 665 during the newest earliest book, but Nicolas Flamel was a real historical contour and you may wouldn’t reach that age up to 1996, within the date the first publication is actually authored. The rebuttal for it is the fact that big date this new “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world will not communicate with the fresh Nicolas Flamel out-of Harry Potter.

Other state is obtainable out-of Rubeus Hagrid’s period because the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is required from the collection you to Hagrid received you to definitely reputation within this many years regarding his expulsion out of university from inside the 1942. However in one scene regarding Harry Potter and also the Goblet out of Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper seem to overlap which have Molly’s age in school, it appears to be impractical that she recalls an earlier gamekeeper. Yet not, you’ll be able to you to definitely Hagrid failed to be an effective gamekeeper quickly immediately following getting expelled, but alternatively already been since the Ogg’s assistant. It is plausible given that whenever Harry thinks that he usually feel expelled to possess traveling into the broomstick instead permission within his first year, the guy magic if however be allowed to stay on because Hagrid’s assistant.